Quality mental health service delivery is increasingly focused on providing a recovery oriented and rights-based approach to care. Achieving this aspiration will require ‘the right number and equitable distribution of competent, sensitive, and appropriately skilled health professionals’ (WHO, 2021, p4). Given nurses typically make up the largest occupational group within healthcare settings, their impact on future mental health service delivery is arguably the greatest. Therefore, it is necessary to examine how adequately prepared nurses working in mental health settings are, and the implications of current approaches for mental health service users.
We compared the minimal education requirements to work as a registered nurse in a mental health setting in five countries: Australia, Ireland, Germany, Denmark and France. Through clarification and comparison, we found profound differences in course accreditation, curriculum content, hours of supervised placement, assessable competencies, support for transition to practice, and protected legal title on completion of the course. Given these differences, it is concerning that once registered, scope of practice is similar across all five countries; even though the registering bodies in four of the countries do not recognize mental health nursing as a sub-speciality within the discipline of nursing.
Of the five countries compared, Ireland is the only country to acknowledge mental health nursing as a sub-speciality within the discipline of nursing; nurses are prepared, registered, and legally recognized as Psychiatric Nurses. This approach creates mental health service delivery where service users and families can be assured that the nurse caring for them has been educated and assessed against standardized competencies determined by the Nursing and Midwifery Board Ireland and has undertaken prescribed supervised clinical hours in mental health settings. In comparison the minimum requirement to work in mental health services in Australia, Denmark, France and Germany is general nursing registration. With varying amounts of mental health content and practice requirement incorporated into general nursing courses.
Mental health service users have a right to meet nurses with required competencies to deliver evidence based, recovery-oriented care. If nurses are to lead and impact on future mental health service delivery, we must begin by adequately preparing mental health nurses.